Nov 8 2022

What's so important about legal precedent?

60 min 3 movies discussed
Listen

Legal precedent is an odd thing. It matters, but it isn't codified. There are advantages and disadvantages. Let's all dive in and take at STARE DECISIS today.

AI Summary

# Stuff You Should Know: Legal Precedent

This episode dives into the fascinating world of legal precedent and how court decisions shape society in ways you might not even realize. Josh and Chuck explore the origins of common law in medieval England, explain the crucial concept of "stare decisis" (letting the decision stand), and break down how the U.S. Supreme Court actually decides when it's okay to overturn previous rulings. From Brown v. Board of Education to more controversial cases, you'll discover why the stability of law matters just as much as getting it right, and how a handful of Latin words and judicial philosophy have shaped everything from your basic freedoms to how justice gets served in America.


Movies Discussed

Brokeback Mountain
Brokeback Mountain
2005 R 2h 14m
★ 7.8
"They're like, we all just saw Brokeback Mountain and we really feel differently about this. — Referenced as an example of how cultural attitudes changed regarding same-sex relationships, used humorously when discussing the Supreme Court's reasoning in Lawrence v. Texas." — Chuck
Buck Rogers in the 25th Century
Buck Rogers in the 25th Century
1979
★ 6.9
"We're flying around and we look like Buck Rogers in the 21st century, I guess, that'll be 22nd century. — Used as an example of futuristic society to argue that the law should evolve with society rather than remain stuck in originalist interpretation." — Josh
Law & Order
Law & Order
1990
★ 7.3
"They said, but it's already in all the TV shows. Exactly. Law and order editors were just like, please don't, please don't. — Referenced when discussing the reliance factor in keeping Miranda rights as precedent, noting how embedded it had become in popular culture."

💬 Comments

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!